We were 6 weeks from losing our merchant account. Here’s the number that saved it.
It wasn’t revenue or churn. It was a ratio I had never checked, and the line it had to stay under is now 1.5%.
In July our acquirer sent us one email. It had our dispute ratio in it, a threshold I had never looked at, and a deadline.
The threshold was 1.5%. We were at 2.4%.
If you run a subscription business, here’s how to tell you might be in the same place:
- You know your refund rate. You don’t know your dispute ratio, which is the number your acquirer actually watches.
- Your customers dispute instead of cancelling. The cancel button works; they use their bank app instead.
- Your anti-fraud tool says you’re fine. Your chargeback report says otherwise.
30 seconds · no email
A while back Stripe closed our account. No warning, no reason we could act on, and no human to talk to. The email was polite and final.
We did what most subscription companies do next. We got our own MID through an acquirer. Higher fees, a reserve, a relationship manager whose name I learned once.
Then nothing happened for a long time. Payments cleared. Trials converted. I stopped thinking about it.
Then July. A Tuesday night, laptop open to clear the inbox before bed. Between a renewals report and a newsletter sat an email from our acquirer’s risk team. I read it twice, took a screenshot and sent it to my co-founder. He wrote back one word: “How?”
The email said our VAMP ratio for June was 2.4%, the Excessive threshold in our region was now 1.5%, and they wanted a remediation plan in 15 calendar days. First identification, so three months of grace before fees.
We weren’t doing anything shady. That didn’t matter.
I had to look up VAMP.
It’s Visa’s monitoring program. The math is short: fraud reports plus disputes, divided by your settled card-not-present transactions. If one transaction gets both a fraud report and a dispute, it counts twice.
The line used to be 2.2%. Since April 1, 2026, it’s 1.5% in the US, Canada, Europe and Asia Pacific. Mastercard’s Excessive Chargeback Merchant program sits at the same 1.5%, once you pass 100 chargebacks a month.
In our terms: at 67,420 card charges a month, 1.5% is 1,011 disputes. A month. Spread across every trial that converted and every renewal someone didn’t expect, that’s not many. We had 1,618. Visa only names a merchant once the count passes 1,500 a month, but smaller businesses don’t get a pass: the acquirer watches the ratio long before Visa does.
The part I didn’t get until later: Visa grades acquirers too. If an acquirer’s whole portfolio goes above 0.5%, it’s flagged as Above Standard. Above 0.7%, Excessive.
So my acquirer wasn’t waiting for Visa to find me. I was already a problem in their numbers.
I pieced the next steps together from Visa’s fact sheet, my acquirer and my PSP’s docs. If the ratio doesn’t come down, each step costs more than the one before.
Monitoring. You get identified, you owe a remediation plan, and someone starts checking your ratio every month.
Fines per count. Once Visa identifies you (over the line and past its minimum monthly count), merchants pay $4 to $8 for every fraud report or dispute, depending on how their acquirer is graded. Mastercard’s program fines start in month two at $1,000 and climb to $100,000 a month from month 19. Mastercard only lets you out after three straight months under its threshold.
Termination. If the numbers don’t improve, the acquirer can close the MID rather than keep absorbing the fines.
The list. Terminated merchants can be added to Mastercard’s MATCH list or in Visa’s merchant screening service. Visa listings stay active for 5 years. That’s what the next acquirer checks before they board you.
For a subscription business, losing the MID means your renewals stop until another acquirer takes you on. A listing makes that much harder.
The timing made it worse. Trials we start in November and December turn into disputes in January and February. If your ratio is climbing into December, the acquirer’s email lands in February, when the counts are already in.
If you don’t know which side of 1.5% you’re on, see where your ratio sits right now. It takes two numbers.
Anti-fraud. We already paid for it. It’s good at catching fraud. Most of our disputes weren’t fraud.
When I read through a month of them, I kept seeing the same customer. A real person with a real card who started a trial, forgot about it, and then saw a charge they didn’t recognize. A lot of them tapped “I don’t recognize this” in their banking app. That often lands as a fraud report, and under VAMP fraud reports count.
Trial reminders. We already sent them. Visa requires a reminder at least 7 days before a trial converts to a paid charge. Mastercard asks for 3 to 7 days. We were compliant. It barely moved the ratio.
Fighting disputes. We sent evidence and won a fair share. The ratio didn’t care.
A recovery service. We tried one with a big “up to” number on its homepage. It got some money back. The ratio didn’t move, because recovering money after a chargeback still happens after the chargeback.
Everything we had worked before the dispute or after it. Nothing worked in between.
Winning a chargeback doesn’t take it out of the ratio
It took me a week to accept this. A dispute is counted the day it’s filed. Whether you win it later changes your revenue, not your ratio.
The fix was in Visa’s own fact sheet, in the fine print on how the ratio is calculated:
“Excludes disputes resolved through pre-dispute solutions, contingent on the timing of the data extract.”
When a cardholder complains to their bank, it doesn’t turn into a chargeback right away. There’s a short gap first. During that gap, the merchant can get an alert: this customer is disputing this charge.
If you refund in that gap, the dispute is resolved before it becomes a chargeback, and Visa leaves it out of the ratio. One catch: a plain refund isn’t enough. It has to go through an alert network your PSP or an alert service connects you to, and not every bank is on one. Fraud reports are a separate line. A refund doesn’t erase one, so those still need the usual anti-fraud work.
I started calling it the pre-dispute window. It lasts hours, and “contingent on the timing of the data extract” means it only counts if it’s closed before Visa pulls the month’s numbers. Slow means counted.
Yes, you give the money back. For a forgotten trial that’s often money you’d lose in the chargeback anyway, plus the fee. And even the disputes you win stay in the count. A refund costs you the charge. A chargeback can cost you the charge, the fee and a step up the ladder.
That’s why the other tools didn’t help. Anti-fraud works before the complaint. Representment works after the chargeback. The window is the only place where a dispute can be stopped from counting.
Run your own numbers through the same math before January’s disputes land.
I connected pre-dispute alerts through Chargebackhit.
When a cardholder starts a complaint, we get the alert and refund inside the window. Most of those never became chargebacks. The customer who forgot about a trial gets their money back without a fight, and if we’re fast enough, that dispute stays out of our ratio.
Alerts didn’t fix everything. A fraud report still counts, and an alert doesn’t take it back. What brought those down was making the charge easy to recognize: a billing descriptor with our product name in it, and a short email on the day of every renewal, not just the first one.
The numbers, as I tracked them:
- Week 0: 2.4%
- Week 6: under 1.5%, before the acquirer’s deadline
- Week 9: 0.8%
The next email from our acquirer was two lines long: ratio 0.80%, no further action required.
I also run the business differently now. I know our dispute ratio the way I know MRR. I check it every month, and I know what January is going to look like before it arrives.
If you want to know your number before January does, check it here: 30 seconds, no email.
“This sounds like a big integration.”
It wasn’t for us. Connecting alerts was paperwork and a few settings, not an engineering sprint.
“Refunding every alert sounds expensive.”
Compare it to the right number, not to zero. The alternative, once you’re identified, is $4 to $8 per count on Visa, Mastercard fines that start at $1,000 a month and climb to $100,000, and, if it ends in termination, a listing the next acquirer will see for years.
“My ratio is probably fine.”
Maybe. I thought so too. Checking takes 30 seconds, and you need two numbers you already have.
Check your ratio
Two numbers from last month and your PSP. No email. Your numbers stay on this page.